[EyeSore] Hugo 3D Review

[Hugo]

   “Hugo” is Martin Scorsese's first run at a 3D motion picture, and one of the few 3D films actually shot for the format.

   This is instantly noticeable as the film begins its opening shots. Hugo, our main character, is introduced as he goes about his daily chores around his home. This home isn't as you would expect, as Hugo resides in the massive clock tower of a train station. Our first shot of Hugo follows him through the entire station, one of the largest full sets I have seen in recent memory, without ever cutting. For anyone who still doubts 3D in modern film today, see this opening shot and your opinion will instantly change. The camera adds huge depth as it zooms  in and around Hugo as he runs through the inter-workings of a clock, past pipes and cogs all without a single cut. Even though Hugo failed to be my favorite film of the year, this was easily my favorite scene.

   Sadly the amazing quality of it's opening is never quite reached again. The film eventually becomes just standard fair, with a few 3D scenes interspersed amongst the story. Now those scenes do stand out as the best 3D has to offer today, but they barely make up 10 minutes of the film. -1

   As for said story, it will appeal to a very limited crowd, and definitely not the crowd it is directed at. Aimed for children as a kids film, “Hugo” passes them over completely with a mature coming of age story, primarily made for adults. With the bulk of the story surrounding an old 'real life' silent film director Georges Melies, and his prior work, the movie instantly alienates average viewers.

   Most people will become lost midway through, around when the mystery behind who Georges is becomes revealed. It is a huge build up, for frankly a poor reveal. The audience was expecting more. And while I found it did add to the overall story, it took the film into an entirely different direction. -1

   This essentially splits the film into two halves. The first part is filled with amazing scenery, a detailed mystery that keeps you guessing, and truly mind blowing 3D effects. Then suddenly the second part kicks in, and the story begins. Everything comes to a screeching halt. The mystery is over, we leave the train station far to often, and the 3D becomes unnoticeable. All of this begins to cause a drag, and where the first hour and a half went by in an instant, I suddenly found myself checking the time. There is no way a small child would sit through the second half, and have any understanding of what was happening, let alone enjoy it. -

   Score aside I want to make it clear, as a film major, I completely understood and loved this film. It does run a bit too long, but was easily worthy of its Best Picture Nomination.

“Hugo” Gets a 7 out of 10.